December 1980, Volume 30, Issue 12

Original Article


A. Qadir AlAwad  ( WHO. Fellow-Present address: Amman, Jordan. )
N.A. Jafarey  ( Department of Pathology, Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre, Karachi. )


Aspiration biopsy was performed in 52 patients with palpable breast masses to evaluate the technique in diagnosis of breast lesions. The procedure was found to be reliable, simple, quick and acceptable. It is a good adjunct to frozen section where this facility is available. In places where his-topathology services are not readily available, aspiration biopsy is a useful technique for confirming clinical impression prior to surgery (JPMA 30:264, 1980).


Although cytologic examination of aspiration of fluid from body cavities had been sporadically attempted as long as syringe and hollow needles have been available, extensive use of aspiration biopsy as a routine diagnostic pro­cedure was initiated by Martin and Ellis in 1926 (Martin and Ellis, 1930) at the Memorial Hospital, New York. The procedure did not gain wide acceptance in the United States and remained limited to few centres (Kline and Neal, 1978). With the popularization of cytological diagnosis in the early 1950s, there has been a renewed interest in aspiration biopsy and the procedure became very popular in the Scandinavian countries (Franzen and Zajicek, 1968; Esposti et al., 1968; Zajicek et al., 1970). In many other centres in Europe (Zajdela et al., 1975; Furnival et al., 1975; Joffe et al., 1979), and Canada (Deschenes et al., 1978), the procedure is a diagnostic method in all breast tumours.
Aspiration biopsy of breast is indicated in all cases of palpable breast tumours. Even nonpalpable breast tumours can be aspirated under radiological guidance (Bolmgren et al., 1977).

Material and Methods

In a period of six months commencing from September, 1979, fifty-two patients with a clinically palpable breast lump were subjected to aspiration biopsy prior to surgery. Cases were collected from three hospitals irrespective of age, sex and disease. The equipment used was a 20c.c. Luer-Lok Syringe and a 19-gauge needle. The tumour was fixed in one hand and a sterilized needle attached to a 20c.c. syringe was intro­duced into the lump. Local anaesthesia was needed in some cases. Once the needle reached the tumour the plunger of the syringe was withdrawn as far as possible to create a vacuum in the system. Then, the plunger was released slowly to its previous position. The needie was advanced or directed to another position in the tumour and the procedure repeated. The pressure was released slowly and the needle withdrawn from the lump. The syringe was filled with air and the drop of fluid in the needie expressed gently on a clean glass slide. A thin film was made and fixed immediately while still wet in 95% ethyl alcohol for about 30 minutes. The smears were stained by Papanicolaou\'s method and a cytologic diagnosis was made and compared with the histologic diagnosis.

Results and Observations

Table-I shows that aspiration biopsy was successful in 46(89.5%) cases while no cellular material was obtained in 6(11.5%) cases. A correct diagnosis was made in 44(84.6%) cases while in two cases cells were seen but the diagnosis was inconclusive. No false diagnosis was made.

Table-II shows the accuracy of cytologic diagnosis in 23 histologically verified malignant lesions of breast. In 20(87%) cases a correct diagnosis of carcinoma was made on cytology. In 1(4 3%) case the smear showed atypical epithelial cells but was rich in inflammatory exudate so a conclusive diagnosis was not made. In 2(8.7%) cases aspiration did not yield enough epithelial cells for diagnosis.
Patients with proven diagnosis of carcinoma were followed for a period of 3-8 months. No complication which could be attributed to aspiration biopsy was found.

Table-III shows the cytologic findings in 29 histologically verified benign tumours. Benign cells were seen in 24(82. 8%) cases. In one (3.4%) case a mitotic figure was seen and a suspicion of carcinoma was raised. In 4(13.8%) aspiration yielded either a cellular cystic fluid or it was unsuccessful.


The accuracy of aspiration biopsy of breast lesions in this study is comparable to many published results (Deschenes et al., 1978; Esposti et al., 1968; Hajdu and Melamed, 1973; Koiv-uniemi, 1976; Kreuzer and Boquo, 1976; Zajdela et al., 1975). The technique was found to be simple, quick and acceptable. No complications were encountered as reported by others (Schondorf, 1978).
A major objection to the use of this technique was the possibility of tumour spreading locally or distally. Local extension of tumour cells along the needle tract has been investigated thoroughly by Engzel et al (1971), Rosemond et al (1974), Franzen and Zajicek (1968), Kline and Neal (1978) and no evidence of local spread of tumour cells was found. Ferrucci et al (1979) reported the first occurrance of needle tract im­plantation in a case of carcinoma of pancreas aspirated twice with 3 passes each time.
The question of disseminating tumour Cells through blood and lymph vessels has also been discussed by many authors (Kline and Neal, 1978; Kern, 1979; Zajdela et al., 1975; Zajicek et al., 1970). Berg and Robbins (1962) compared the 15-year survival rates of 379 patients with breast carcinoma diagnosed by aspiration biopsy with the same rate of 370 patients diagnosed by other methods. They concluded that the only difference in prognosis elicited by various methods favoured rather than discouraged aspiration biopsy.


1. Berg, J.W. and Robbins, G.F. (1962) A late look at the safty of aspiration biopsy. Cancer, 15:826.
2. Bolmgren, J., Jacobson, B. and Nordenstrom, B. (1977) Stereotaxic instrument for needle biopsy of the mamma. Am. J. Roentgenol., 129:121.
3. Deschenes, L., Fabia, J., Meisels, A., Toth, B.V., Gagnon, J.C., Savard, H. and Shirley, L.M. (1978) Fine needle aspiration biopsy in the management of palpable breast lesions. Can. J. Surg., 21:417.
4. Engzel, U., Esposti, P.L., Rubio, C, Sigurdson, A. and Zajicek, J. (1971) Investigation on tumour spread in connection with aspiration biopsy. Acta Radiol., 10:385.
5. Esposti, P.L., Franzen, S. and Zajicek, J. The aspiration biopsy smear, in diagnostic cytology and its histological basis, by Koss, L.G. 2nd. ed. Philadelphia, Lippincott, 1968, pp. 565-96.
6. Ferrucci, J.T. Jr., Wittenberg, J., Margolies, M.N. and Carey, R.W. (1979) Malignant seeding of the tract after thin-needle aspiration biopsy. Radiology, 130:345.
7. Franzen, S. and Zajicek, J. (1968) Aspiration biopsy in diagnosis of a palpable lesions of the breast. A critical review of 5,479 consecutive biopsies. Acta Radiol. (Ther), 7:241.
8. Furnival, C.M., Hughes, H.E., Hocking, M.A., Reid, M.M.W. and Blumgart, L.H. (1975) Aspiration biopsy in breast cancer, its relevance to diagnosis. Lancet, 2:446.
9. Hajdu, S.J. and Melamed, M.R. (1973) The diagnostic value of aspiration smears. Am. J. Clin. Pathol., 59:350.
10. Joffe, S.N., Hughes, H.E., Primrose, J.N. and Williamson, H.W.A. (1979) Aspiration cytology and outpatient exces-sion of breast lumps. Lancet, 2:294.
11. Kern, W.H. (1979) The diagnosis of breast cancer by fine-needle aspiration smears. JAMA., 241:1125.
12. Kline, T.S. and Neal, H.S. (1978) Needle aspiration biopsy. Critical appraisal. Eight years and 3,267 specimens later. JAMA., 239:36.
13. Koivuniemi, A.P. (1976) Fine-needle aspiration biopsy of the breast. Ann. Clin. Res., 8:272.
14. Kreuzer, G. and Boquo, E. (1976) Aspiration cytology, mammography and clinical exploration: A modern set up in diagnosis of tumours of the breast. Acta cytol., 20:319.
15. Martin, H.E. and Ellis, E.B. (1930) Biopsy by needle puncture and aspiration. Ann. Surg., 92:169.
16. Rosemond, G.P., Maier, W.P. and Brobyn, T.J. (1974) Needle aspiration of breast cysts. J. Fam. Pract., 1:61.
17. Soderstrom, N. Fine-needle aspiration biopsy. New York, Grune and Stratton, 1966.
18. Schondorf, H. Aspiration cytology of the breast. London, Saunders, 1978.

Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association has agreed to receive and publish manuscripts in accordance with the principles of the following committees: