M. F. Khan ( Family Physician, D-161, KDA Scheme No. 1, Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre, Karachi. )
S. Haroon Ahmed ( Department of Psychiatry, Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre Karachi. )
In a working class industrial area of Karachi hundred consecutive Pathans presenting to a family physician with potency disorder were examined. After exclusion of those with structural or drug related conditions, a structured proforma was introduced. Their presentation, associated symptoms and background pointed to masked depression and lack of sex education. Symptoms of anxiety were noticed in 49% and depressive features in 43%. The guilt feelings were reinforced by Hakims and lay literature which stress more on masturbation (79%) and spermatorrhoea (60%) and not extra-marital intercourse (52%) or bestiality (39%) (JPMA 40:12, 1990).
In Indo-Pakistan subcontinent sex related disorders are common in all communities irrespective of ethnicity or geographical boundaries. The variations in the manifestation may be due to socioeconomic and cultural differences, the common feature being lack of sex education. Generally the knowledge acquired is through traditional tales of sexual prowess and advertisements of magic remedies by quacks.
The Pathans living in Karachi have special features. They live away from home and work tobe able to marry and support their family. The deviation in the fulfillment of their sexual role can beverytraumatic.A studyof their sexual behaviour is expected to be revealing.
The group studied consisted of working class Pathans, coming mostly from rural areas and hilly regions of North West Frontier Province. These people, robust physically, are highly volatile emotionally and tribal rivalry is prevalent. Educational facilities are meagre and the children often help the parents in the farms or grazing family sheep. Strict religious and tribal laws govern their lives. For example if a boy and girl are seen together in privacy the matter is settled through tribal laws which may be shooting the couple by their own parents.
There is no choosing of the partners, the marriages being arranged by the parents and exchange is the preferred method. If a man has a sister, he gets married easily at an early age otherwise he has to earn and wait. Child marriages are common.
Karachi is a melting pot of various cultural, ethnic and linguistic groups and religious sects. They comprise of migrants from India and immigrants from Punjab, Baluchistan and NWFP.
Since partition the population swelled from 436,000 in 1941 to 2.048 million in 1961 to over 8 million now, including about 1.5—2 million Pathans. The affluent pathans are in transport business or shopkeepers (fresh and dry fruit) but the majority are labourers in mechanized or construction industry. They are employed as manual workers, drivers and chowkidars (guards). Their work is extremely hard with no leave. A taxi or mini bus driver works from 6 in the morning till late at night. The chowkidar is on duty for 24 hours.
PATIENTS AND METHOD
Information on hundred consecutive patients belonging to working class of industrial area presenting with potency disorder was entered on proforma. All patients presenting with sex related disorders were given thorough physical examination and those with organic basis (structural or drug-related) were excluded.
General physical weakness (80%), body ache (31%) and backache (24%) are the main presenting complaints besides potency disorder Other symptoms are equally vague. Spermatorrhoea was complained by 60% which is occasional¬ ly prostatitis but usually rectal massage of prostate due to constipation. ‘Fever’ not recordable on thermometer was complained by 15%. In psychiatric practice this is not unusual presentation of depression in Pathans and acceptable reason of absenteeism from work. Although only six patients were found to be clinically depressed, others denied depressed mood, but presented with fami¬liar somatic features of masked depression. Soma¬tie manifestation of depressive illness in develop¬ing countries is amply documented1-3. In a study on depressed patients in Karachi4 the frequency of somatic symptoms were giddiness 82%, palpita¬tion 80%, headache 77% and general weakness 66%. Once they are conscious of their potency disorder it waS made worse through reinforcement by Hakims. Majority were practising Muslims (85%), living away from their spouse (48 out of 74 married), and sexual urges satisfied through masturbation (79%), homosexuality (45%) or heterosexual (52%) activity. This is in conformity with earlier studies on patients attending as psychiatric out patient and among male university students in Karachi5,6. Bestiality was admitted by 39%. It was not surprising that masturbation, spermatorrhoea and homosexualityproduced much more guilt than extramarital heterosexual contacts (52%) or bestiality (1%). The size and direction of erect penis was considered by others to be the main cause of their problems. It is concluded that masked depression and anxiety could be the main reason of potency disorder among the Pathans in Karachi. The lack of sex-education is reflected in their guilt feelings which relates closely to the popular belief that masturbation, Spermatorrhoea or intercourse during menstruation causes sexual weakness, and not bestiality.
1. Binitie, A. A factor-analytical study of depression across cultures (Africa and Europe). Br. J. Psychiatry, 1975; 127: 559.
2. Murphy, H. B., Wittkower, E.D. and Chance, NA, Cross-cultural inquiry into the symptomatology of dcpression; a preliminary report. Int. J. Psychiat., 1967; 3: 6.
3. Teja, J.S., Narang, RL and Aggarwal, A.K. Depression across culture. Br.J. Psychiatry, 1971; 199:253.
4. Ahmcd, S.H. and Arif, M. Culture and Syrnptomatology in depression. PakistanJ. Med. Res., 1982; 21: 64.
5. Ahmed, S.H. Disorder of potency in males. JPMA., 1975; 25:336.
6. Ahmed, SJI. Attitude towards sex and sexual problems among male University students. JPMA., 1981; 31:59.