September 1992, Volume 42, Issue 9

Original Article


Rehana Maher  ( Department of Dentistry, Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre, Karachi. )
Ayyaz Khan  ( Department of Dentistry, Shaikh Zayed Federal Postgraduate Medical Institute, Lahore. )
Salim Rahimtoola  ( Department of Dentistry, Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre, Karachi. )
Douglas Bratthall  ( Department of Cariology, WHO Collaborating Centre for Research Education and Training, University of Lund, Malmo, Sweden. )


The caries status of two hundred and eighteen 12 year old school children from four schools of Karachi and Lahore was determined through a WHO pathfinder survey. In addition, the levels of mutans streptococci in the sample were estimated in order to define the proportion of children with high and low mutans levels. A mean DMFT of 1.82 (1 .67-0.03-0.12), for decayed and filled teeth respectively; 42% were caries free. Four mutans streptococci; 22% had mutans class 0, 22% class 1, 31% class 2 and 25% class 3. The mean DMFT was respectively, 1.0+1.23, 0.98 + 1.52,2.03+2.36 and 3.04 + 3.08. The difference was statistically significant. Twenty four children had 5 or more DMF all except two of them, belonging to mutans classes 2 or 3 (JPMA 42: 213,1992).


Dental caries, a multi factorial disease, is caused by bacterial deposits on the tooth surfaces. After intake of fermentable carbohydrates, bacteria in these deposits may lower the local pH to a level where the minerals of enemal and dentin dissolve. Factors which interact in this process, include organic and inorganic components in saliva. Fluoride is another substance which interacts strongly in the caries process and favours remineraliza­tion of the affected tooth after the bacterial attack has ceased. The balance between the collective cariogenic factors and the resistance factors of teeth and saliva decides whether cavities will occur on a tooth surface in an individual or in a population. For Pakistan, the present overall balance on a population level seems to be comparatively favourable. A national caries survey1 shows a mean DMFT level of 1.2 for 12 years old (one of the ‘WHO indicator ages) which means that less than two teeth per person were decayed (D), missing (M) or filled (F). This caries level is, according to WHO very low. However, it is easy to understand that the balance is not for all times. The WHO Global Oral Data Base indicates that changes for the worse have occurred in national caries figures following increased sugar and sweets consumption and for the better, after the introduction of effective preventive programmes. The main etiological factors for dental caries should therefore be identified in various com­munities and countries2. For caries, oral hygiene pat­terns, diet and fluoride have traditionally been the major issues but the mutans streptococci of the viridans group have also been identified as most cariogenic3-5. In­dividuals with higher mutans prevalence usually have about three times more caries than those without or with very low levels of these bacteria6,7.The aim of the present study was to extend a caries pathfinder survey and determine the prevalence of mutans streptococci and its correlation with dental caries.


The sample consisted of 220 twelve years old children selected from four schools, two in Karachi and two in Lahore. Two of these schools had earlier par­ticipated in the national caries survey. The four schools were:
St. Joseph School Karachi
This school for girls admits children of high socioeconomic families throughout Karachi.
Aga Khan School, Karachi
The families sending their boys to this school come mainly from lower middle class.
Federal Government Girls School, Lahore
The school has children from low to very low socioeconomic families.
Garrison School, Lahore
A school for boys only. The majority of the children were from low to middle class from mixed geographical areas.
Examinations for caries were performed according to the methods outlined in WHO Oral Health Surveys (3rd ed., Geneva) by four experienced examiners. Microbiology: For estimation of the levels ofmutans streptococci, the “strip mutans" kit was used (Orion Diagnostica, Helsinki, Finland) 8,9. Prior to the clinical examination, the child chewed paraffin to stimulate saliva and remove bacteria from the teeth. A plastic strip included in the kit was rotated in the mouth and over the tongue. Excess saliva was removed by withdrawing the strip through closed lips of the individuals. The strips were incubated in selective broth for 48 hours. The selectivity is based on a combination of high sucrose and bacteria in the broth together with the ability of the mutans bacteria to adhere to the strip. The number of adherent colonies was compared with a chart supplied by the manufacturer and given a score between 0 and 3, indicating low (_ 105 CFU-colony forming units) saliva to very high (_ 106 CFU) per ml saliva mutans counts. Two samples were lost due to heavy gas formation from unidentified bacterial species growth. The final group consisted of 218 children. Statistical methods: Anova was used to test the significance of differences among groups. When the analysis of variance rejected the multi sample hypothesis of equal means, multiple comparison test analysis using Scheffe’s test was performed. The tests were two-tailed and at a 95% significance level.


The results are presented in Tables I-IV and Figure.

The mean DMFT for the total sample was 1.82 ±2Y35 (standard deviation) with 67- 0.003-0.12 for decayed, missing and filled teeth respectively. DMFS was 2.46 (Table I). Children in Karachi had lower DMF values compared to Lahore children. Almost all fillings recorded were found among children of St. Joseph School in Karachi (Table I). Of the total samples, 91 children (41.7%) were caries free (Table II). Twenty four (9.1%) children had 5 or more DMFT. Highest recorded caries score was 14 DMF teeth.
For mutans streptococci, 22% of children had mutans class 0, 22% class 1, 31% class 2 and 25% class 3 (Table III). The mean ± was 10± 1.22, 0.98± 1.52, 2.03 ± 2.36 and 3.03 ± 3.07 respectively. The differences were statistically significant (p = 0. 0001, mutans classes 0 and 1 = class3). Table IV shows frequency distribution of DMFT in relation to mutans classes. Of the children with 5 or more DMFT, all except two had mutans classes 2 or 3.


The caries levels found in the present study of Karachi confirm findings of the national caries survey conducted in 19881. In that survey, a mean DMFT of 1.07 was recorded and two Karachi schools had 1.38 and 1.0 respectively. For Lahore, the values were higher as national survey had only 1.11 DMFT for the urban sample in Punjab. However, the mean values from all schools were still low according to WHO terminology. Neverthe­less it is apparent that both preventive and restorative services are needed for the children, as very few fillings were recorded and in fact, practically all fillings had been done on children from one school in Karachi. In the total sample, 363 teeth needed restorations (13 of them already had fillings) and 27 teeth had filings without new caries. For comparing mutans streptococci levels for dif­ferent countries, it is necessary that the same methodologies are being used as different methods differ in sensitivity to detect the micro- organisms and the scales may have been set differently10-12. The “strip mutans” method enluates mutans streptococci in saliva which reflects the number of teeth colonized by these bacteria, the main habital for mutans streptococci13-15. A high saliva count (strip class 3) indicates that 80-90 percent of the tooth surfaces are colonized by bacteria, while a low count (strip class 1) or lower means that some 10 percent or less of the surfaces are carrying mutans streptococ­ci15,16. In the age group of 12 years,the proportion of populations having very low levels of mutans (strip class 0) may vary from 7 to 30 percent and high counts (strip class 3) 10 to 50%6,17-20. Thus, for the total sample, the values for Pakistan fall with these ranges. For most countries studied so far, the group with high mutans counts has had about three times more caries than the group with low mutans counts. When discussing the relationship between mutans and caries, it is important to consider the multifactorial background of this disease. It can be expected that an individual with high mutans levels and a high sucrose intake develops more caries than a person with only one of these unfavourable factors. If, however, the caries challenge is met by effective prevention, the individual may be caries free inspite of mutans streptococci and even sucrose intake. That means that in a survey, all different combinations mutans caries can be found. A person “without” mutans streptococci (strip class 0) may have caries. Some tooth surfaces may carry the bacteria but not to the extent that they are present in the saliva sample. The individual may have used antibiotics which temporarily suppress the mutans streptococci or the resistance may be so low, or the sucrose intake so high that other bacteria may cause caries lesion. As biochemi­cal and clinical evidences point to a strong cariogenic potential of the mutans streptococci, a correlation should be found in a sample like the one presented in this study. Such a significant correlation was demonstrated in the total sample (Table III and Figure). Children with scores 2 or 3 had actually 2.5 times more caries than those with score 0. Because of the positive relationship between the high mutans count and caries this method can be used to identify the population at a higher risk to develop the disease.


This study was supported by .WHO and by Patentmedelsfonden for Odontologisk Profylaxforskn­ing.


1. Maher, R. Dental disordersin Pakistan. a national pathfinderstudy.J. Pat Med.Assoc., 1991;41:250-52.
2. Brstthall, D. and Barmes, D.E. Oral Health. In Health Sector Priorities Review. Edited by D.T. Jamison. Population, Health and Nutrition Division, Population and Human Resources Department,The World Bank, Washington D.C., 1990;1-25.
3. Hamads, 5. and Slade, H.D. Biology, immunology and cariogenicity of streptococcus mutans. Microbiol. Rev., 1980;44:331-84.
4. Emilson, C.G. and Krssse, B. Support for and implications of the specific plaque hypothesis. Scand.J.Dent.Res., 1985;93:96-104.
5. Loesche, W.3. Role of streptococcus mutans in humsn dental decay. Microbiol. Rev., 1986;50:353-80.
6. Carisson, P. On the epidemiology of streptococcus mutans. Ph.D. thesis, University of Lund, Malmo, Sweden, 1988;1-56.
7. Bratthall, D. Theglobal epidemiology of mutans streptococci. In Dental Caries: Markers of high and low risk groups and individuals. Edited by N.W. Johnson. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1991; 1:287-311.
8. Jensen, B. and Bratthall, D. A new method for the estimation of mutans streptococci in human saliva. J. Dent Res., 1989;68:468- 471.
9. El-Nadeef, M.A.l. and Bratthall, D. lntraindividual variations in counts of mutana streptococci measured by "strip mutans" method. Scand.J.Dent.Res., 1990;99:8-12.
10. van Palenstein-Helderman, W.H., ljaaeldijk, M. and Hula in T. Veld, J.H.J. A selective medium for the two major subgroupa of the bacterium atreptococcus mutans isolated from human dental plaque and aaliva. Arch.Oral.Biol., 1983;28:599-603.
11. Tanzer, J.M., Borjesaon, AC., Lakowaki, L., Kuraaz, AS. and Testa, M. Glucose. sucrose-potassium tellurite-bacitracin agar, an alternative to mitis salivarius-bacitracin agar for enumeration of streptococcus musana.J. Clin. Microbiol., 1984;20:653-59.
12. Bratthall, D. and Carisson, P. Clinical microbiology of saliva. In: HUman saliva; clinical chemiatty and microbiology. Edited by J. Tenovuo. CRC Press. Boca Raton, Florida, 1989;2:204-41.
13. Emilson, GO, Axelason, P. and Kallenberg, L Effectof mechanicaland chemical plaque control measures on oral microflora in school-children. Com­mun.Dent.Oral.Epidemiol., 1982;10:111-16.
14. Kristoffersson, K. More or less of streptococcus mutans. Relation to dental caries and caries preventive measures. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Lund, Malmo, Sweden, 1986; 1-40.
15. Lindquist, B. Mutans streptococci in human dentition. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Goteborg. Goteborg, Sweden, 1991;1-36.
16. Lindquist, B., Emilson, CO. and Wennerhoim, K. Relationship between mutans streptococci in saliva and their colonization of the tooth surfaces. Oral.Microbiol.Im­munol., 1989;4:71-76.
17. Twetman, S., Mattiasson, A., Varela, R.J. and Brstthall, D. Mutans streptococciin saliva and dental caries in children living in a high and a low fluoride sret Oral.Microbiol.Im­munol., 1990;5:169-71.
18. El-Nadeef, M.A.L Distribution of mutans streptococci among Nigerian school children. MasterThesis, University of Lund, Malmo, Swedeçi, 1991;1-35.
19. del Rio, 0.1. Dental caries and mutans streptococci in selected groups of urban and native Indian school children in Mexico, Commun.Dent.Oral.Epidemiol., 1991;19:98­-100.
20. Shi, Y., Barmes, D., Bratthsll, D. and Leclerq, M.H. WHO Pathfinder caries survey in Beijing extended with data for prevalence of mutans streptococci. Int.Dent.J., 1992;42:31-36.

Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association has agreed to receive and publish manuscripts in accordance with the principles of the following committees: