By Author
  By Title
  By Keywords

January 1993, Volume 43, Issue 1

Original Article

ACUPUNCTURE VS CARBAMAZEPINE IN TRIGEMINAL NEURALGIA

M. Salim  ( Department of Anaesrhesiology, Military Hospital, Rawalpindi. )

INTRODUCTION

In Pakistan carbamazepine (tegretol) is invariably prescribed for patients suffering from trigeminal neural­gia. The initial dose is 100-200 mg twice daily orally. In some eases as much as 1600 mg may be required. Side effects include dry mouth, dizziness, drowziness, diar­rhoea, nausea, etc. In some cases skin rashes, jaundice and leucopenia were also seen1. The study was undertaken to compare the effects of acupuncture in patients suffering from trigeminal neural­gia.

PATIENTS METHOD AND RESULTS

During the last 5 years we treated 36 cases of trigeminal neuralgia who reported to our pain clinic. All of them were on carbamazepine (tegretol) for more than one month and had no pain relief. Male to female ratio was 1:3 (male 9 and female 27). Two acupuncture needles were inserted at point taiying (about 2 cm outer side of eye canthus) and yangbai (about 2 cm above the eyebrow) on the affected side. For half an hour needles were stimulated with (BT 701 electroacupuncturc machine) low frequency and high intensity. This form of stimulation is thought to inhibit pain by activating enkephalinegic interneurones in the dorsal horn and invoke production of endorphins in the brain2. Treat­ment was continued for 15 days as first course of treatment. After interval of 2 weeks second course was started in few patients. Maximum 2-5 courses were needed for most of the patients to get maximum benefit. Fifteen patients showed excellent improvement. They stopped taking all drugs. There was no recurrence for 2 years. In 9 patients intensity of pain was much reduced and duration of pain was less. They described their pain ‘just bearable’. In another 8 patients response was variable. Four patients showed no change at all in their pain character or intensity.

COMMENTS

Carbamazepine is the drug of choice for the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia3. Phenytoin or baclofen can also be used. The most popular operation consists of lesioning of the gasserian ganglion but have a high relapse rate. The patients who are not benefitted with drugs or surgical intervention or by repeated nerve blocks should have trial of acupuncture. In has no side effects. This study was conducted in those patients who were already taking drugs. A control study might he more helpful.

REFERENCES

1. Nimmo, W.5. Drugs affecting the autonomie and central nervous systems, in clinical pharmacology. Edited by Ronald A. Girdwood 25th ed. London, Bailliere Tindall, 1984; pp. 199-268.
2. Bonica, J.J. The managementof pain. Philadelphia, Lea and Pebiger, 1989; 687-726.
3. Ponser, J.B. Disorders of sensation, in Cecil\\\'s text boot of medicine. 18th ed. Philadelphia, Saunders, 1988; pp. 2128-37.

Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association has agreed to receive and publish manuscripts in accordance with the principles of the following committees: