By Author
  By Title
  By Keywords

November 1995, Volume 45, Issue 11

Original Article

Self Medication or Self Care: Implication for Primary Health Care Strategies

Sohail Haider  ( Faculty of Health Sciences, Baqai University. Karachi. )
Inayat H. Thaver  ( Faculty of Health Sciences, Baqai University, Karachi. )

Abstract

To determine the frequency cy of self-medication, a cross-sectional study was conducted in a Karachi district by selecting households through systematic random sampling. Health seeking behaviour for childhood illnesses and assessment of the magnitude and reasons for self-medication were done by interviewing mothers/caretakers. Five hundred households were visited, of which 158 fulfilled the criteria of having one sick child in the previous month. Medication without prescription was given to 51.3% children, mostly consisting of unidentified drugs or analgesics/antipyrelics. Good past experience (61.3%) with the medi­cine was the main reason for self-medication. The use of medicines by health professionals was the main reason influencing parents for self-medication to their children. Self-medication is difficult to eliminate, but interventions can be made to discourage use of inappropriate and harmful drugs (JPMA 45:297,1995).

Introduction

Self-treatment starts from diagnosing a problem, choos­ing medication or treatment and ends by administering it without professional assistance1. Thus different definitions have been suggested2,3 which emphasize legitimate utilization of non- prescribed medicines. Self-medication practice varies in different geographical areas4,5, socio-economic circum­stances6,7 and in different perceived diseases8-10. It is usually employed for self-limiting diseases or for those taken to be harmless. Professional care is sought when results do not meet the users expertions11. Besides people resort to self medication, because has helped them in the past. Self-medication is traditional implicated as hazard­ous12 and always discouraged. Self-care aspect of self-medi­cation has not attracted the attention of researchers and programme planners specially related to Primary Health Care (PHC). However, a number of strategies like oral rehydration therapy, early assessment of pneumonia, early nutritional assessment and intervention, are recommended as first level care and are expected to be employed by mothers or lay persons. This community-based study was carried out to identify the health seeking behaviour of mothers/care- takers for childhood illnesses and assess the magnitude and reasons for self-medication.

Material and Method

A cross-sectional study was done to determine the pattern of self-medication in one district of Karachi with slum and non-slum areas by selecting the households through systematic random sampling. Of 500 house holds selected, 342 had children less than 12 years of age. One hundred and fifty-eight house holds were finally included in which at least a child was ill during last month. Mothers or guardians/care­takers of the children were interviewed by a questionnaire. Data was analyzed by using EPHNFO.

Results

Of the 158 children included in the study, 81 were self-medicated. The mean age of children was 4.3 (SD 3.5) years. They suffered from acute respiratory infectious diarrhoea, (40.5%) and vomiting (33.5%), fever (17.7%) and various other problems (8.3%). Mean duration of illness was 5 days. The immediate response to illness in 63% children was by giving medicines within 3 days. Traditional remedies were used in 20.9% whereas 16.5% opted to “wait and see”. Later almost all of them (96.8%) received medicines. Half (51.3%) the children were given medicines without any valid prescription (self medicated), 11.5% on the suggestion of shopkeepers, 9.0%by family members and 3.2% by influence of advertisements. Medicines were mainly suggested either by prescription or verbally by doctors in 55.1% and other health personnel in 14.7% cases. Self-medication to children was done because of a good previous response to medicines (61.3%), to save time and money (21 .3%) and inaccessibility of doctors (15.0%). Except for antibiotics (10.8%) and anti-diarrhoeal/anti-emetics, (11.3%), most of the drugs were not hazardous (Table).

Self medication was significantly associated with illit­eracy and rural origin of families (P<0.0001). Infants were more self- medicated specially for diarrhoea as compared to other illnesses. More antipyretics, analgesics and anti-diar­rhoeals were used than the other medicines.

Discussion

The practice of self-medication is known all over the world. Literature describes an excess of indiscriminate use of antibiotics and anti diarrhoeals by health professionals. The lay- man self-prescribes on the basis of a good past experience or to save time, economic reasons or inaccessibility to doctors. Complete eradication of this practice would not be possible, but offering a more appropriate alternative system could discourage the use of harmful drugs, both by health profes­sionals and consumers. Self-care system as preached through primary health care needs the attention of policy planners and programme managers. Early identification of signs of dehydration and pneumonia, personal hygiene, improved nutrition, family planning and first aid can all be the in-package of the self-care system. A project in Nepal based on these concepts has shown promising results13. More operational projects in different areas should be started based on the concepts of self-care, instead of traditionally criticizing self-medication practices.

References

1. Briegar, W. R., Ramakrishna, J. and Adeniyi, JD. Self-treatment in rural Nigeria. A community health education diagnosis. Hygie., 1986;5:41-46
2. Maiti. C.K., Guantai, A. and Mwangi., J.M. Self medication in management of minor health problems in Kenya. East Afr. Med. J., 198 1;58:596-600.
3. Hardon, A. Confronting ill health medication, self care and the poor in Manila, Health Action Information Network, 1991, p. 13.
4. Haak, H., Vanden Schaaften, B. J. and Grrothog, J.W. Medicine use amongst pupil of a continuation school in Haren, Tijdschr. Social Genzondheidsjorg, 1987;65:439.40.
5. Krishna Swamy, K., Kuman, D. and Radhaiah. 0. et al. A drug survey perccpts and practices. Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol., 1985;29:363-370.
6. Quah, SR. Self medication in Singapore. Singapore Med. J., 1985;26:123-29.
7. Abo Sede, O.A. Self medication: An important aspect of primary health care. Soc. Sci. Med., 1984;19:699-703.
8. Adiwar, D. H. and Manafe, R. Self medication to treat diarrhoea in children under five. Health Action International, 1988 ;4: 1-32.
9. Foster. S. D. Pricing, distribution and use of Antimalarial drugs. Bull. WHO.. 1991;69:349-63.
10. Angst, J., Vollrath, M., Koch. R. et al. The Zurich study VII. Insomnia; Symptoms, classification and prevalence. Eur. Arch. Psychiatry Neural. Set., 1989;238:285-93.
11. Stoller, E.P. Prescribed and over the counter medicine use by the ambulatory elderly medical care. Drug utilization Study, 1984,26:1149.57.
12. Link, C.K., Gau, J.P.C.H. and Wang, S.Y. Aplastic-anemia in Taiwan and its etiological factors. Taiwan-l-Hsueh. Hui. Tsa. Chih, 1989;88:1123-7
13. Kafle, K.K. and Gartoulla, R.P. Self medication and its impact on essential drugs scheme in Nepal. A socio-cultural research project. WHO/DAP/93. 1993, pp.1-20.

Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association has agreed to receive and publish manuscripts in accordance with the principles of the following committees: