By Author
  By Title
  By Keywords

July 1996, Volume 46, Issue 7

Case Reports

‘Menouria’ - A Presentation of Vesicouterine Fistula

Shereen Zulfiqar Bhutta  ( Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology. Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre, Karachi. )

Vesicouterine fistulae account for Ito 4% genitourinaiy fistulae1. They are primarily a complication of lower segment Caesarean section and were extremely rare till 19472 . The incidence has gone up since then, because of increasing rates of Caesarean sections2-5. Unlike other gcnitourinaiy fistulac, urinary incontinence is not an integral feature ofavesicouter­ine fistula1,2,4,6. When the defect is above the level of internal os, the woman is continent but the menstrual flow is diverted to the bladder causing haematuria. This phenomenon of cyclic haematuria, apparent amenorrhoea, in the presence of a patent cervix with urinazy continence is referrd to as Youseff’s syndrome7. Youseff coined the term \\\'Menouria\\\' for vesical menstruation in these cases. This article describes five women with Menouria presenting to the department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre, Karachi over the last seven years.

Case Reports

A 28 year old pam 3+0 presented with painless haematuria lasting 5 days for the last 3 months. The last delivery was 8 months earlier, her third Caesarean section with tubal ligation. There was no other urinar complaint. She was amenorrhoeic since delivery. Physical examination, labora­tory investigations and intravenous pyelogram (IVP) were unremarkable. Ultrasound examination showed a communi­cation between the bladder and uterus just above the cervix (Figure 1).

This was confirmed by hysterography and cystoscopy. A total abdominal hysterectomy with bladder repair in two layers was done. The bladder was drained for 10 days with a Foley’s catheter. She remains free of symptoms 7 years later.
Case 2
A 41 year old pam 6+0 admitted in shock following prolonged obstructed labour at home, had emergency lapara­torny. The stillborn foetus weighing 4.2 kg was removed from the peritoneal cavity. The transverse rupture in the lower uterine segment resembling a Caesarean section incision, as well as a 4 cm transverse rupture in the bladder base were repaired in two layers and tubal ligation was done. Bladder was drained continuously with a Foley’s catheter. Despite a patent catheter, urinary leakage through the vagina was noticed on the seventh post-operative day. A gentle examina­tion through the still open cervical os revealed the bulb of the catheter palpable through a small defect through the site of the rupture. Bladder drainage was continued for another three weeks. Urinaiy leakage ceased and she went home completely continent. She reported back after 12 weeks, with two episodes of frank haematuria lasting 4 days at a month’s interval. Cystoscopy showed a 2 cm central vesicouterine fistula 2 cm above the trigone. The patient refused further evaluation and treatment. She remains well 6 years later with persistent cyclic haeniaturia, preferring it to the previous more cumbersome way of managing her menstmal periods.
Case 3
A 22 year old para 2+0 had delivered by second Caesarean section 9 months back. For the last 3 months she had frank painless haernaturia lasting 4 to 5 days every month and was amenorrhoic since Caesarean section. The  physical examination, laboratory investigations and IVP were normal. Cystoscopy showed a 1 cm vesicouterine fistula 1.5 cm above the trigone and hysterography demonstrated spill of contrast medium into the bladder (Figure 2).

She was prescribed the combined oral contraceptive containing 0.05mg oestradiol, continuously for 6 months to suppress menstruation. She remained asymptomatic during this period but haematuria recurred on stopping the pill. Repair was carried out through the transabdominal transperitoneal route, exposing the fistu­lous tract, mobilising the bladder off the uterus, cervix and uppervagina Both the organs were repaired in two layers. The bladder was drained for 12 days by Foley’s catheter. Normal menstruation resumed following surgety. She has sub­sequently had deliveiy of a term baby by elective caesarean section alongwith tuballigation.
Case 4
A 26 year old pam 1+0 had an elective caesarean section for breech presentation 10 months earlier. She presented with painless gross haematuria lasting 6 days on two occasions a month apart and was amenorrhoic since Caesarean section. No abnormality was detectable on examination, laboratory inves­tigations and IVP. Cystoscopy showed a 0.5 cm vesicouterine fistula 2 cm above the trigone, which was also demonstrable on hysterography (Figure 3).

Continuous administration of the combined oral contraceptive containing 0.05 mg ocstradiol, resulted in resolution of cyclic haematuria and return of normal menstruation. She has since had a live birth by an elective Caesarean section at term and remains free of symptoms.
Case 5
A 26 year old para 2+0 had second Caesarean section 20 months. earlier. She remained amenorrhoeic after stopping breast feeding but had frank painless haematuria every month lasting 3 to 4 days. The examination and IVP were uninforma­tive. Ultrasound cystoscopy and hysterography confirmed the fistula between the bladder base and uterus above the cervix. Examination under anaesthesia after instilling 150 ml of dye showed no abnormality, but on putting another 300 ml of dye into the bladder, the same was seen escaping through the cervix7. A transperitoneal abdominal repair of the bladder and uterus after adequate mobilisation was carried out in two layers (Figure 4).

Foley’s catheter was left in the bladder for 12 days. There was no haematuria post-operatively and normal menstruation resumed. The couple are using barrier contra­ception presently.


A vesicouterine fistula presenting with vesical men­struation and urinary continence was first reported in 19358. Various mechanisms have been postulated for this. These include the presence of an isthniic sphinctor7, granulations on the posterior uterine wall occluding the internal uterine orifice1,9 and the intrauterine pressure being higher than the intravesical pressure6. Diagnosis can be made by a non-inva­sive technique like ultrasound, as in two of our cases, but the mainstay remains hysterography and cystoscopy. The latter is essential to determine the exact. location of the fistula in the bladder and determine its relationship to the uretenc orifices. An 1\\\\TP may not assist in diagnosis, but is mandatory to know the status of the upper urinary tract.
Spontaneous closure of the fistula has been reported4,10-13 and is worth waiting in fistulae presenting early. Suppres­sion of menstruation with hormone therapy is another conser­vative treatment associated with favourable outcome3,5,7 and cured one of our patients. interestingly vesical menstruation itself does not necessarily cause harm14-17.
Cystopscopic fulgration of the fistula is a feasable option18  for women not desiring further pregnancies3. An- other alternative for them is abdominal hysterectomy and bladder repair. For those who wish to retain fertility, repair should be able to svithstand the stress of subsequent pregnan­cies. This is best carried out transperitoneally thmugh thc abdominal route, with or without an interposed omental graft1-3 Fertility following repairwas thought to be extremely low19, but this is not çormboratcd by others20  or us. The two women in this report who had subsequent pregnancies conceived within three months of discontinuing contracep­tion.
Vesicouterine fistual is a rare but largely preventable complication of Caesarean section. Complete preoperative emptying and adequate intraoperativereflectionofthebladder from the uterus, with timely recognition and repair of any injury to the bladder minimises such complications.


1. Lenkovsky, Z.. Pode, D.. Shapiro. A. et al. Vcsicoutcnne lisiula: A rare complication of caesarean section. 1. UroL. 1988; 139:123-5.
2. Tancer. M.L. Vesicouterine listula - A review: Obstet. Gynecol., Surv.,1986;41:743-53.
3. Thanos, A.. Paviakis, A.J. and Davillas, N. Vesicouterine fistuli, Urology, 1986;28:426-8.
4. Raunch, R.J., Rodgers, MW. Spontaneous closure of a vesicoutering fistula following caesarean section. JAMA 1962,181:997-9.
5  Rubino SM. Vesicouterine fistula treated by amenorrhoea induced with contraceptive steroids. Two case reports. Br. J. Obstet. Gynaceol., 1980:87:343­-44.
6. Hemel. AK., Wadhws, SN., Kriplani, A. et al. Youseff\\\'s syndrome: An appraisal of hormone treatment. Urol. Int., 1994;52:55-7.
7. Youseff, A.F, \\\'Menouria following lower segment caesarean section. Am. J. Obstct. Gynaccol.. 1957;73:759-67.
8. Machado, L.M. Vesico-cervical fistulas after caesarean section. Rev. Fr. Gynccol. Obstet 1935:29-471.
9. Hudson, C.N. Vesicoutcrinc fistulas after caesarean section J. Obstct. Gynecol. Brit. Comm. With., 1962;69:121-4.
10. Sims, G.K. Spontaneous healing in a vesicouterine fistula following labor: Report of a case. JAMA 1928;90:759-60.
11. Frankel T and Buchosbaum, H.J. Vesicocorporeal fistula with menouria. J. Urol., 1971;106:860-1.
12. Grazzioti,P, Lanbo, A. and Artibani, W. Spontaneous closure ofa vesicouterine fistula after caesarean section. J. Urol., 1978; 120:372.
13. Buchspan. MB.. Simha. S. and Klotz, P.G. Vesicouterine fistula: A rare complication of caesarean section. Obstet. Gynecol.. 1983;62:645-665.
14. Burr, G.C. Uterovesical fistula. J. Urol., 1939;41 :906.
15. Medeiros, A., De, S. and Guimaracs, MV. Youseff\\\'s syndrome: A case report. 3. Urol., 1973;109:828-9.
16. Bond, W. and Rogers, G, Unusual vcsicouterinc fistula. Am. J.Obstet. Gynecol, 1952;63:2 15-6.
17. Falk, H.C. and Tancer. ML. Management of vesical fistulas after cesarean section. Am. J. Obstet. Gynccol., 1956;71:97-106.
18. Molina, L. R., Lynne, CM. and Politano, V.A. Trcatmentofvesicouterinc fistula by fulgration. J. Urol., 1989;141 :1422-3.
19. Dubbuisson, J.B., Barbot, J. and Santarelli, J. Les fistules vesico-uterines apres operation cesarienne, J. Gynecol. Obstct. Biol Reprod. (Paris), 1979;8:229.
20. Issa, M.M., Schmid, H.P. and Stamey, TA. Youseff\\\'s syndrome: Preservation of uterine function with subsequent successful pregnancy following surgical repair. Urol. Int., 1994;52:220-2.

Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association has agreed to receive and publish manuscripts in accordance with the principles of the following committees: