Bilal Jamil ( The Kidney Centre, Karachi. )
Haren Kumar ( The Kidney Centre, Karachi. )
S.A.J. Naqvi ( The Kidney Centre, Karachi. )
One hundred and five patients enrolled in the maintenance haemodialysig programme at The Kidney Centre were studied retrospectively to identifLpg ac_t§f§§c§v_a§§gciated _incr,e3t.Sed.mortalitys. t Hypertension (relative risk 10.03, P<0.001), serum albumin <3 G/dl (relativierisk 2.60, p<0.05), diabetes mellitus as a cause of End Stage renal disease (relative risk 2.54, p<0.001), age >55 years (relative risk 1.8, p) were associated with higher risk of mortality, while sex had no statistically significant effect JPMA 46:58, 1996).
Dialysis decreases the mortality and morbidity of patients with End Stage Renal Disease (ESRD), however, all patients do not benefit to the same extent. Various factors including age1-3, race1,2, sex1 , diabetes mellitus as a cause of renal failure2-4 . low serum albumin2,5-7, low serum choles- terol2,7 , low urea reduction ratio5 and coexisting illness like left ventricular failure3, ischemic heart disease4 and hypertensions8 are associated with increased risk of mortality in these patients.
This study was carried out to study some of the risk factor identified in the literature which predict the mrotality of patients with ESRD on maintenance haemodialysis and to ascertain the extent to wich the survival of these patients can be predicted.
Patients and Methods
All patients who entered the maintenance haemodialysis programme at. The Kidney Centre from July 1, 1989 to July 1, 1992 were included in the analysis.
Their medical records were scrutinized for their age at initiation of haemodialysis, ‘sex, duration on dialysis, cause of end stage renal disease, predialysis serum albumin before enrollment, presence or absence of hypertension, diabetes mellitus and ischemic heart disease (IHD). All patients underwent acetate dialysis for four hours twice weekly.
The medical records were studied till July 1, 1994 ie, study termination, death of the patient or if he left the Centre. The survival results are presented in terms of relative risk (RR) and survival rates are based on Kapalan Meiers methods9.
Of 105 patients studied, 40 expired during follow-up, 13 left the Centre, (9 for a transplant and 4 for dialysis at other Centres). Fifty two patients were alive at the temiination of study. There were 63 males and 42 females, with a male to female ratio of 1.5:1. Theirage ranged from 18-80 years (mean 48+14.1 years, median 47 years). The mean duration on dialysis was 31+14.8 months.
Diabetes mellitus was the leading cause of End Stage Renal Disease, followed by Chronic Glonienilonephiitis and hypertensive nephropathy (Table I).
Mortality was highest (72%)in the diabetics and hypertensives (50%). All patients with adult polycystic kidney disease (APKD) were alive at the termination of study, their mean duration on dialysis being 43.2 months (range 28-53 months).
To see the effect of age on mortality, the patients were divided into three groups, below 45 years, between 45-55 years and over 55 years. The mortality in these groups was 28% 48% and 58% respectively (Table II),
with the male to female ratio being 43% to 44% (Table II). Comparison of diabetics and non-diabetics is shown in (Table III).
Mortality increased as serum albumin decreased with a 100% mortality in those having senim albumin <3 G/dl in Er-it—rast to 12% in those having serum albumin >5 G/dl (Table II). The survival curves of diabetic and non-diabetics are shown in Figure 1,
hypertensives and non-hypertensives in
Figure 2 and those based on serum albumin in Figure 3.
Age is a recognised risk factor affecting mortality of patients on haemodialysism1,2, with a risk of death approxi- mately doubling every 10 years3 . This fact was confirmed in the presented study. Males are described to be at a higher risk of death, than females1,2, however in this study this was not true. A similar ﬁnding is reported by Mac Clellan et al4.
The relative risk of death in diabetes was 2.54 as compared to non-diabetics in this study. This has been shown in other studies5. Hutchison et al3 have described duration of diabetes to be the strongest predictor of prognosis. The mean survival of diabetics in this study was 24 months which is far less as compared to the western ﬁgures. Watanabe et al6 showed a 50% survival of 60 months on haemodialysis. This might be due to the acetate dialysis which is poorly tolerated by these patients as compared to bicarbonate dialysis. In this study patients with adult polycy stic kidney disease had abetter survival. Similar ﬁndings are reported in literature7,8. This is attributed partially to higher average hemoglobin levels which protect them to some extent from ischemic cardiac deaths8.
Mortality was high in patients with low serum albumin and all subjects having a serum albumin <3 g/dl died within 2 years of initiation of maintenance haemodialysis. Serum albumin <4 g/dl has been described as a powerful predictor of death2,9,10 and a serum albumin <3 g/dl was associated with greater probability forhospitalization forany cause11. Foley et al12 found that serum albumin <3 g/dl was not associated with early death i.e., within six months of initiation of haemodialysis. Low senim albumin is an indicator of malnutrition in these patients13. Intensive assessment of malnutrition and aggressive therapeutic intervention improves the survival of cases on dialysis14.
Hypertension was associated with a greater risk of mortality in this study. Adequate control of hypertension by aggressive ultrafiltration improves survival of patients on dialysis7,15 . Ischeniic heart disease affects long teim7 as well as short term12 survival of these cases.
Of the various risk factors identified in this study, the two which can be corrected are low serum albumin and diet counselling for the fomier and aggressive ultra-filtration combined with medication for the latter, provides a relative reduction in the mortality risk for patients on maintainence haemodialysis.
1. Held, P.J., Pauly, M.V. and Diamon, L. Survival analysis ofpatients undergoing dialysis JAMA, 1987;257:645-650.
2. Lowric. EG and Nancy, L L- Death risk in haemodialysis patients The predictive value of commonly measured variables and an evaluation of death rates differences between facilities. Am J. Kidney Dis, 1990;15:458-482.
3. Hutchinson, T.A., Thomas, D.C. and Mac-Gibbon, B Predicting survival in adults with end stage renal disease. An age equivalence Index. Ann. Intern. Med, 1982;96:417-423.
4. Mac—Clellan, W.M., Flanders. W.D. and Gutman, R.A. Variable mortality rates among dialysis treatmentcentres. Ann. Intern Med, 1992;117:332-336.
5. Mc~Mil1arL M.A , Briggs, J.D and Junor, i.i.J.R. Outcome ofrenal replacement treatment in patients with diabetes mellitus. Br. Med. J., 1990;301:540-544.
6. Watanabe, Y., Yuzawa, Y.,Mizumnto,U.eta1. Long temi follow-up study of268 diabetics undergoing hemodialysis, with special attention to visual acuity and lieterogenecity. Nephrol. Dial. Transplant, 1993:8;725-734.
7. Charra, B , Calemard, 12., Ruffet, M et al. Survival as an index ofadequacy of dialysis. Kidney Int, 1992,41 1286-1291.
8. Ritz, E., Zeier, M, Jones, E. et al Cardiovascular mortality of patients with polycystic kidney disease on dialysis is there a lesson to learn. Nephron, 1994;66:125-128.
9. Owen, W.F., Lew, N.L., Lie, Y. et al. Theurea reduction ratio and serum albumin concentration as a predictor of mortality in patients undergoing hemodialysis. N. Engl.J Med., 1993;329:1001-1006.
10. Gold Wasser, P., Mittman, N., Antignami, A. et al Predictors of mortality in hemodialysis patients. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol 1993;3:613- 1622.
11. Churchill, D.N., Taylor, N., Cook, R J. etal. Canadian haemodialysis morbidity study. Ann J. Kidney Dis , 1992;19:214-234.
12. Foley, R.N., Parfrey, P.S , Hefferton, D et al. Advance prediction ofearly death in patients starting maintenance dialysis. Am.J. Kidney Dis., 1994;23:836-845.
13. Hakim, MR. and Lerin, N. Malnutrition in hemodialysis patients. Am. J. Kidney Dis., 1993121125-137.
14. Safdar, N. Importance of nutrition in dialysis patients. (Editorial) J Pak Med Assoc , 1994;441:271.
15. Scribner, 13.1-I. Adequate control of blood pressure in patients on chronic hemodialysis (Editorial). Kidney Int, 1992;411:1286.