April 1998, Volume 48, Issue 4

Editorial

Childhood Tuberculosis

S.Q. Nizami  ( Department of Paediatrics, The Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi. )

About eight million people developed tuberculosis iii 1990 and 2.6 to 2.9 million people died of it, mostly in Asia It is estimated that one third of the world’s population (1700 million) is infected with Mycobacterium tuberculosis1. The disease is not limited to Asia alone and its prevalence is increasing in developed countries also where it is linked to Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS)2. The disease is more common in adults over 50 years of age, in developed countries and under 50 years in Asian and African countries. Tuberculosis in children is uncomnion in developed countries and is encountered, mostly in children living in underprivileged areas3 or in immigrant population4. The prevalence of the disease in children was declining in Europe5 and United States6 but due to AIDS, the decline has been arrested. In spite of this fact, a low prevalence of tuberculosis was seen in children with AIDS. InAbidjan, only one childout of78 childrenw ith AIDS was diagnosed to have tuberculosis7. The situation in developing countries is different where malnutrition and tuberculosis coexist8 and the threat of AIDS is imminent. Diagnosis of tuberculosis in children is also difficult9. Mostly, the cases are diagnosed on clinical evidence alone as isolation of Mycobacteria is difficult due to non-availability of sputum. In addition, the notification system is either not present or the cases are not notified to the competent authority. Hence, there is hardly any reliable data available from developing countries about the true prevalence of childhood tuberculosis. Recently there have been improvements indiaguostic techniques both in rapid isolation of Mycobacteria10 and by indirect evidence such as Enzyme Linked Immunosorbent Assay11,12 and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR)13. Radiometric system, i.e., BACTEC system gives the results in two to three weeks instead of conventional cultures on Lowenstein Jensen media giving results in six to eight weeks10. Of the indirect tests, PCR is so far the most reliable test detecting Mycobacterial DNA with a sensitivity of 40%-90% and specificity of 80%-90%13-15 and may be done on body secretions and blood.
The treatment of tuberculosis is standardized and the six month regime of short course chemotherapy16-18 including Pyrazinaniide in the initial two months of therapy is highly effective in all forms of the disease including extra pulmonary diseases suchas tuberculous meningitis19. But increasing drug resistance20 of Mycobactcrium tuberculosis to INH and other drugs poses a problem in the management of childhood tuberculosis due to difficulty in isolating the Mycobacteria and determining their sensitivities to the antitubercular drugs, Compliance to drug therapy is another problem. In a study in Karachi, only about one third of the children receiving antitubercular therapy were followed for six months (unpublished data). This lack of compliance of patients indicates the necessity of directly observed therapy (DOT) which has been successfully used in other developing countries like India and Bangladesh. This approach has been recommended to be adopted in the National Tuberculous Control Programme of Pakistan21. Unfortunately, this programme is directed mainly toward sputum producing adult tuberculous patients and children have been included in category III. The approach of targeting only the population, which is responsible for spread of the disease, is essential for its rapid control but care of future generation should not be compromised. Other significant aspects of this programme are inclusion of thiacetazone and exclusion of rifarnpicin during continuation phase and increased duration of therapy, i.e., eight months. Increased duration of therapy from six to eight months might increase the problem of compliance but will reduce the emergence of resistance of Mycobacteria to rifampicin. in such a situation DOT assumes an important role.
Prevention of tuberculosis is also very important. Prevention of tuberculosis lies in case finding and treatment of sputum positive adult patients, which is the targeted population of National Tuberculous Control Program. In spite of this, the role of DCG immunization cannot be overlooked. Though the role ofBCG immunization in neonates and infants inpreventing tuberculosis22 has been questioned but its role in preventing severe fonus of tuberculosis has not been denied. It is still recommended23,24 for routine immunization of children in countries with high prevalence of tuberculosis.

References

1. Sudre, P., Dam, U. and Kochi, A. Tuberculosis: a global overview of the situation today. Bull.WHO.,1 992;70: 149-59.
2. Drucker, E., Alcabes. P., Bosworth, W. e t a!. Childhood tuberculosis in the Bronx, New York. Lancet, 1994;343:1482-85.
3. Goodyear, P.M., Moore Dillon, IC., Price, EH. eta!. Mycobacterial infection in sinner city children hospital. Areh.Dis.Child,,1993;69:229--31.
4. Management and outcome of chemotherapy for childhood tuberculosis. Medical Rearch Council Tuberculosis and Chest Diseases Unit. Arch.Dis. Child.,l 989;64: t 004-12.
5. Silverman, NI. Childhood tuberculosis in Britain. Br.Med.J., 1 988;297. 1147-48.
6, Riedcr, H.L.. Cauthen, G.M., Comstock, OW. et a!. Epidemiology of tuberculosis in United States. Epidcm ol. Rev., 1989;l 1 .79-98.
7. Lucas, S.D., Peacock, CS., Hounnou, A. et al. Discase in children infected ith HIV in Abidjan CoLe d’Ivoire. Br.Med.J, I 996;3 12:335-38.
8. Vijsyakumar, M., Bhaskaram, P. and Hemalatha, P Malnutrition and childhood tuberculosis. J.Trop.Pcdiatr., I 990;36:294-98.
9. Osborne, C.M. The challenge of diagnosing cbildhood tuberculosis in a developing country. Areh.Dia.Child., 1995;72:369-74.
10. Schaaf H.S., Nel, ED., Bcyers, N. et al. A decade of expcrience with Mycobacterium tuberculosis culture from children: a seasonal influence on incidence of childhood tuberculosis. Tubercle;Lung Dis., I 996;77:43-46.
11. Barrera, L., Miceli, I., Ritacco, V. et al. Detection ofeirculating antibodies to purified protein derivative by enzyme linked immunoaorbcnt assay: its potential for rapid diagnosis of tuberculosis. PediatrJnfeet.Dis.J., 1989;11 :763-67.
12. Hussey, G., Kibel, M. and Dempster, W. The serodiagnosis of tuberculosis in children: an evaluation ofan ELISA test using tg0 ntibodies to M. tuberculosis strain H37Rv. Ann. TropPediatr., 1991; i 1:113-18,
13. Smith, K.C., Starke, J.R., Eisenach, K. et at. Detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in Clinical Specimens from children using a polymerase chain reaction. Pediatrics, 1996;97:1 55-60.
14. Eisenach, K.D., Stitford, M.D., Cave, M.D. etsi. Detection of mycobscterium tuberculosis in sputum samples using a polymeraae chain reaction. Am.RevRespir.Dis., 1991 ;144:1 160-63,
15. Manacao, MY., Nolte, ES., Nshmiss, A.J. et al. Use of polymersse chain reaction for diagnosis of tuberculous meningitis. Pediatr. Infect,Dis.J., 1994;13:154-56.
16. Biddulph, J. Short course ehemutherspy for childhood tuberculosis. Pedistr.lnfect.Dis.J., 1990;9 794-801
17. Bass, .1.8., Farer, L.S., Hopewell, P.C. et at. Treatment of tuberculosis and tuberculosis infection in adults and children. American Thoracie Society and The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention! Am.J.Respir.Crit.Care Med. 1994;149: 1359.74.
18. Grosset, J.H. Present status of chemotherapy for tuberculosis. Rev.Infect.Dis., 1989;Supp 2:5347-52.
19. Jscubs, R.F., Sunakurn, P., Chotpitayasunonah, T. et at. Intensive short eoursn chemotherapy for tubereulous meningitis. Pedistr, Infect.Dis,J., 1992;1 1:194-98.
20. Join, N.K., Chopra, K.K. arid Prssad, 0. Initial and acquired isoniazid sad rifampicin resistance to myheobseterium tuberculosis and its implications for treatment. Indian 3 Tuberele., I 992;39: 121 -24.
21. National guidelines for tuberculosis eontrui in Pakistan. lslamsbad, Directorate of Tubercuiosis Control, Federal Ministry of Health Pakistan, 1995.
22. Ten-Dam, 14.0; and Hitze. K.L. Does BCG vaccination protect the newbornand young infants? Bull.WHO., 1980;58:37-41.
23. Romsnus, V. Tuberculosis in Bacillus Calmette Guerin immunized and unimmunized children in Sweden: s ten year evaluation following the eessaton of general Bacillus Calmette Guerio immunization of the newbom in 1975. Pediatr.Infect.Dis.J., 198 7;6:272-80.
24. Tidjani, 0., Amedome, A., ten-Dam, HG. The protective effect of BCG vaccination of the newbom against childhood tuberculosis in an African community. Tubercle.,1986;67:269-81.

Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association has agreed to receive and publish manuscripts in accordance with the principles of the following committees: