Muhammad Haseeb ( Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Department, Punjab Dental Hospital, Lahore. )
Kamran Ali ( Department of Oral Surgery, Peninsula College of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Plymouth, United Kingdom. )
Muhammad Faisal Munir ( Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery. Lahore Medical and Dental College, Lahore. )
Objective: To evaluate the frequency of common causes of permanent tooth extraction and severity of dental condition at the time of tooth extraction.
Methods: The cross-sectional study was conducted at the Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Punjab Dental Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan, from February to June 2010, and involved 1026 patients who were referred for the extraction of permanent teeth. The inclusion criteria comprised caries, periodontitis, restoration failure, trauma, and local pathologies, while 3rd Molar impactions, supernumerary tooth extraction and extractions done as part of orthodontic or prosthodontic treatment were excluded. Oral hygiene was recorded using the Simplified Oral Hygiene Index. SPSS version 17 was used for statistical analysis.
Results: The mean age of the study population was 46.60 ± 11.321 years, and there were 611 (59.6%) males. A total of 1178 teeth were extracted. Advanced dental caries was the leading cause of tooth extraction (n=743; 63.1%), followed by periodontitis (n=309; 26.2%) restoration failure (n=54; 4.6%), trauma (n=38; 3.2%) and miscellaneous local pathologies (n=34; 2.9%). More than half of the patients (n=540; 52.6%) had poor oral hygiene.
Conclusion: Advanced dental caries is the most common cause behind tooth extraction.
Keywords: Caries, Periodontitis, Restoration failure, Tooth extraction, Oral hygiene. (JPMA 62: 812; 2012).
Tooth extraction has its own due share of pre-operative and post-operative complications.1 Financial burden and time consumptions on the part of patients and clinical skills on the part of dentists increase to a great deal in restoring a missing tooth than maintaining a healthy dentition.
Owing to the increasing awareness through media, the paradigm of dental health profession even in developing countries has shifted in recent times towards early treatment, but it is still far from being preventive. Prevention of dental diseases on a mass scale has become the mainstay of dentistry in developed countries,2 but this is not well organised in countries with low socio-economic status, early tooth loss is a common observation.
The nature of oral disease and its severity differs in different communities,3 but dental decay affects every community. The severity of oral diseases at the time of presentation outlines the treatment protocol, but features responsible for the disease should be analysed thoroughly as they provide an impetus for oral healthcare awareness and preventive strategies.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the frequency of common conditions leading to tooth extraction in the local population. It also aimed at evaluating the extent of tooth destruction caused by caries in patients presenting for extraction as it is one of the most prevalent condition of tooth extraction worldwide.
The data collected through this study would help to initiate/strengthen programmes aimed at the prevention of dental diseases. Secondly, the evaluation of the severity of dental disease at the time of tooth extraction would generate meaningful policies in healthcare settings.
Patients and Methods
The cross-sectional observational study was conducted from Feb to June 2010 at the Department of Oral Surgery, Punjab Dental Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the hospital. Patients were informed about the nature and objectives of the study and consent was obtained before the procedure. Of the 1200 patients presenting for extraction, 1026 agreed to give their consent for participation (Response rate 85.5%). Oral hygiene was evaluated using the Simplified Oral Hygiene Index (debris index + calculus index).4 Miller\\\'s Mobility Index5 was used to grade the mobility of teeth. Using clinical and radiographic data, diagnosis was made and a precise cause of extraction was established. Only one trained examiner categorised the patients to remove any bias. Single and multiple extractions were recorded separately.
For patients with caries, periapical involvement was judged by radiographic examination. Extent of caries was further categorised according to the destruction of coronal tooth structure. Periodontitis was considered to be the cause for extraction in patients having tooth mobility of grade >2 according to the Miller\\\'s Mobility Index. Detailed operative definition of each inclusion criteria was developed (Table-1).
Extractions of deciduous teeth, supernumerary teeth, wisdom teeth, extractions done as part of orthodontic or prosthetic treatment were excluded.
SPSS-17 was used for data analysis. Percentage distribution of reasons for tooth extraction was calculated along with their respective clinical presentation. Frequency of tooth extraction in different age groups was also calculated.
The mean age presentation was 46.60±11.32 years and the range 13-79 years. The highest number of patients was in the 6th decade of their lives. Among the males, 64 (10.45%) presented with good oral hygiene; 179 (29.25%) had fair; and 3689 (60.30%) had poor oral hygiene status. Amongst the female subjects, the oral hygiene status was good in 98 (23.67%); fair in 145 (35.02%) and poor in 172 (41.30%) according to the index criteria.
There were 1178 extractions carried out in 1026 subjects (1.15+0.20 teeth per patient). Of the subjects, 892 (86.93%) underwent single tooth extractions, whereas multiple extractions were carried out in 134 (13.06%) patients. Advanced dental caries was the leading cause of tooth extraction in 743 (63.1%) patients, followed by periodontitis in 309 (26.2%); restoration failure in 54 (4.6%); trauma in 38 (3.2%) and local pathologies in 34 (2.9%) (Table-2).
The predominant reason for tooth extraction in all age groups was caries (Table-3).
The study was conducted at a tertiary care dental hospital in Lahore. The sample size is a good reflection of dental diseases prevalent amongst the general public in Pakistan. The least number of extractions was carried out in patients below 20 years of age (7%) the reason being the exclusion of deciduous teeth as well as extractions performed as part of orthodontic treatment. Orthodontic extractions have been reported in another study accounting for a substantial percentage of extractions carried out in a younger age group.6 In the present study, percentage of tooth extractions due to caries was considerably high in younger age groups as compared to an earlier study.7
The current study revealed higher frequency of tooth extraction for males; an observation similar to western population sample.8 These findings are in line with the fact that females are generally more conscious about their look and facial aesthetics and tend to seek early dental treatment.
Considerable number of studies have been conducted worldwide to evaluate reasons for dental extractions in different population groups.6-14 Caries has been cited as the most common dental disease leading to tooth extraction in all of the afore-mentioned studies, and results from the current study conform to the previous studies. Caries was the most prevalent condition leading to tooth extraction (63.1%) in the present study. The subset of caries showing involvement of periapical tissues or otherwise gives a useful insight about the severity of the condition at the time of presentation. A higher proportion of patients (32.5%) having periapical involvement presented with loss of one or two walls of tooth crown. However, all cases of retained roots had periapical involvement.
Periodontitis was the second most common dental disease leading to tooth extraction in our study. Considerable percentage of patients (11.4%) presented with periodontitis and with the presence of caries. However, due to grade 2 mobility, periodontitis was considered to be the cause of extraction. Periodontitis was primarily diagnosed amongst patients in their fifth decade or later. These findings are also similar to many international studies which reported periodontitis as the major cause of tooth extraction in the elderly.8-11 Amongst the extraction done for periodontal reason, 17.8% patients were younger than 50 year of age which shows a shear lack of oral health maintenance and awareness amongst our general masses.
Amongst the minor causes of tooth extraction, root canal treatment failure was reported as the main cause of restoration failure. Both subjective and iatrogenic causes can be considered a possible underlying factor, but the extent to which each might have added was not interrogated. Restoration failure was seen equally in all age groups. Dento-alveolar trauma usually leads to fracture of crown and/or root which eventually require extraction. Local pathologies such as odontogenic cysts and benign tumours developing in jaw-bones were the least frequent causes of tooth extraction.
The results obtained from the present study differ from an earlier study12 in which tooth extractions due to periodontal disease (3.0%) were far less than what we found in our study population whereas trauma was the second most common cause of extraction (9.8%). However, caries was still reported to be the most common cause of tooth extraction (61.5%). Differences in the culture, dietary habits and oral hygiene practices might have affected the burden of disease.
Studies from many developed countries have reported significant reductions in the rate of dental caries and the subsequent need for tooth extraction.13-15 In Pakistan, we need to re-direct our health finances towards preventive strategies aiming at reducing the burden of diseases.
Dental community should reform the preventive aspects of dentistry by engaging government, media, and local organisations to carry out the awareness in school-going children and general public regarding oral health care. Strategies must be devised to organize targeted community programmes, fulfilling the needs dictated by the epidemiology of oral diseases in a certain community.
We would like to thank Dr N. Rehan and Muhammad Ghias for statistical assistance.
1. Humber CC, Albilia JB, Rittenberg B. Chronic Osteomyelitis following an uncomplicated dental extraction. J Can Dent Assoc 2011; 77: b98
2. Simonsen RJ. Pit and Fissure Sealants: Then, Now and Next Steps. J Public Health Dent; 2007; 64: 17-22.
3. Wandera M, engebretsen IM, Okullo I, Tumwine JK, Astrom AN; PROMISE-EBF Study Group. Sociodemographic factors related to periodontal status and tooth loss of pregnant women in Mbale district, Uganda. BMC Oral Health 2009; 9: 18.
4. Peter S. Essentials of preventive and community dentistry. Indices in dental epidemiology; 2nd ed. Arya (medi) publishing house, New Delhi: 2003; pp 136-40.
5. Davies SJ, Gray RJ, Linden GJ, James JA. Occlusal considerations in periodontics. Br Dent J 2001; 191: 597-604.
6. Jovino-Silveira RC, Caldas Ade F Jr, de Souza E.H, Gusmão E.S. Primary reason for tooth extraction in a Brazilian adult population. Oral Health Prev Dent 2005; 3: 151-7.
7. Aida J, Ando Y, Akhtar R, Aoyama H, Masui M, Morita M. Reasons for permanent tooth extractions in Japan. J Epidemiol 2006; 16: 214-9.
8. McCaul LK, Jenkins WM, Kay EJ. Reasons for extraction of permanent teeth in Scotland- a 15 year follow up. J Dent 2001; 29: 401-7.
9. Kida IA, Astrom AN, Strand GV, Masalu JR. Clinical and socio-behavioural correlates of tooth loss: a study of older adults in Tanznia. BMC Oral Health 2006; 6: 5.
10. Baqain ZH, Khaisat A, Sawair F, Ghanam S, Shaini FJ, Rajab LD. Dental extraction for patients presenting at oral surgery student clinic. Compend Contin Educ Dent 2007; 28: 146-50.
11. Chestnutt IG, Binnie VI, Taylor MM. Reasons for tooth extraction in Scotland. J Dent 2000; 28: 295-7.
12. Shah SA, Khitab U, Chughtai MA, Khan AS. Causes of dental extractions among 2000 patients - a study conducted at oral and maxillofacial surgical unit, Khyber College of Dentistry, Peshawar - Pakistan. Pak Oral Dental J 2004; 24: 209-12.
13. Cleaton-Jones P, Fatti P Dental caries trends in Africa. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1999; 27: 316-20.
14. Sgan -Cohen HD, Katz J, Horev T, Dinte H, Eldad A. Trends in caries and associated variables among young Israeli adults over 5 decades. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2000; 28: 234-40.
15. Murray H, Locker D, Kay EJ. Patterns of and reasons for tooth extractions in general dental practice in Ontario, Canada. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1996; 24: 196-200.