Parveen Tariq ( Department of Paediatrics, Rawalpindi Medical College, Rawalpindi. )
Zafarullah Kundi ( Department of Paediatrics, Rawalpindi Medical College, Rawalpindi. )
Objectives: To identify the common causes and contributory factors for high neonatal mortality in Pakistan and propose effective strategies to safeguard against it
Methods: This retrospective study was carned out in Neonatal Unit (NNU) of Rawalpindi General Hospital (RGH) from January 1995 to December 19%. Relevant prenatal information obtained from referral forms, admission files or attendants was recorded on a proforma at the time of death of a newborn. This induded obstetric and medical management of the mother, neonatal resuscitation and care, birth weight (wt) and gestational age. Cause of death was based on available clinical and laboratory data.
Results: During the study period, there were 3005 admissions and 268 deaths, resulting in 9% neonatal mortality. Eighty-eight percent of this mortality was due to early neonatal deaths. More than 50% of deaths were unavoidable due to their critical condition at admission and occurred within first 24 hours of hospitalization. Neonatal infections and birth asphyxia were two major causes of neonatal mortality (37% and 31% respectively), followed by idiopathic respiratory distress syndromes (IRDS), Meconium aspiration syndrome (MAS) and congenital malformations. Sixty eight percent of mortality was contributed by low birth weight (LBW), 74% of them being preterm suggesting high mortality among LBW-preterm infants. Other less common contributory factors were maternal medical disease, complicated deliveries and multiple gestation.
Conclusion: These causes and contributory factors of neonatal mortality reflect poor prenatal health services in this country. Hence there is a need for coordinated efforts to organise and regionalize MCH and prenatal health services with the help of a neonatal task force (JPMA49:56, 1999).
Around 12 million children <5 years of age die every year in the third world1 Of this a large majority die before they reach their 1st birthday2 About half of infant mortality is constituted by neonatal mortality, mostly during 1st week of life3,4. There has been a gradual decline in infant mortality in Pakistan during the last 3 decades with little change in neonatal mortality5. This reflects poor perinatal health services and lack of sufficient information about attributable causes of high neonatal mortality in this country6. Although considerable attention has been paid to prevention of mortality from neonatal tetanus in Pakistan7. Other contributory factors need exploration and attention. This study has been undertaken to identify the major causes and contributory factors for neonatal mortality with an urgent need to plan and propose preventive and effective measures to safeguard against its very high incidence.
Subjects and Methods
This retrospective study has been conducted in the neonatal unit (NNU) of Paediatrics Department Rawalpindi General Hospital (RGH) affiliated with Rawaipindi Medical College. The NNU has provision of 10 baby cots, 10 incubators and 20 mother beds. All sick newborns both inborn and outborn (delivered at home, private clinic or other hospital) requiring special and intensive care are admitted in this unit except those with neonatal tetanus who are retained in a separate tetanus ward. Some of the outborns are brought from neighboring towns in a critical condition. All high risk or complicated inborn deliveries and caesarians are attended by a Paediatric resident and a house officer for proper neonatal resuscitation and care. This NNU is equipped with a resuscitation trolly, radiant warmer, glucometer, bilirubinometer, 6 phototherapy units but lacks ventilator, pulse oxymeter or arterial blood gas (ABGs) monitoring facilities. CSF cytological analysis, hemoglobin percentage and urea level are done round the clock in hospital laboratory but rest of the biochemical, metabolic and haematologic screening is done only in the morning hours. One registrar and two house officers, one staff nurse with two senior trainee nurses are on duty in NNU round the clock. Serious babies are monitored two hourly. All neonatal deaths (deaths of newborns within first 28 days of life) from January, 1995 to December, 1996 were recorded on a predesigned proforma. Relevant perinatal information both about the mother and newborn was obtained through obstetric or referral forms and admission files.
Newborns data included gestational age, birth weight (wt), sex, apgar score or history of (H/O) birth asphyxia (delayed cry or bluish discolouration at birth), resuscitation provided at birth, place and mode of delivery, duration of hospital stay, age at expiry, cause of death with contributory factors based on available clinical and laboratory data. Maternal age, parity, multiple gestations, prolonged rupture of membranes (PROM>24 hrs), antepartum haemorrhage, maternal pyrexia (temp >100 F), medical disease and previous obstetric history were also recorded.
Early neonatal deaths were regarded as deaths within 1st 7 days of life. Gestational age was assessed by Parkin scoring. Apgar score at 1 minute of 0-3 was taken as severe birth asphyxia, 4-7 as mild to moderate birth asphyxia and
>8 as normal. Birth weight of <2.5 kg was taken as LBW, 1.0 -<1.5kg as very low birth weight(VLBW) and <1.0 kg as extremely low birth weight (ELBW).
Three thousand and five newborns were admitted in NNU of RGH during the year 1995 and 1996. Out of these 268 expired, accounting for 9% neonatal mortality among total admissions. Among these neonatal deaths, 61% (n=164) were male and 39% (n=104) female. Sixty-eight percent (n==182) of mortality was constituted by LBW and among these, 51% (n=92) had either VLBW or ELBW (Figure 1),
overall 50% (n=135) and among the LBW 74%(n=135) were preterm, (Figure 2).
Place and mode of delivery of neonatal deaths are shown in figures 3 and 4.
Sixty-three percent of RGH delivered deaths were the outcome of unbooked cases (none or <3 antenatal visits). Among normal deliveries (SVDs), 74% (n=144) were LBW. Similarly 65-70% were LBW with respect to their place of delivery. Maternal age or parity had no significant contribution towards LBW among these neonatal deaths as only 17% mothers had age >35 years or parity >5 and the comparison was not meaningful. Thirty percent of mothers had bad obstetric history either due to previous abortions (16%), still births (4%) or neonatal deaths (9°/s).
Eighty-eight percent (n=237) of the neonatal deaths occurred during 1st week of life (figure 5).
Prior to death, the duration of stay in the hospital was <24 hours in 55% (n=147) and >7 days in only 4%(n=l1, figure 6).
Thirty one percent (n=84) newborns needed resuscitation at birth but it was provided only to 25% (n-66). The rest of them (6%) were not resuscitated either because of delivery at home by untrained dai or in a private/other hospital lacking properly trained staff for resuscitation.
frequency (Table I).
Nine percent (n=9) of those with sepsis also had meningitis. The terminal event was disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC) in 15% (n=41) and acute renal failure in 6%(n=16). LBW was the single most common and leading determinant of neonatal mortality. Other contributory factors included maternal medical disease, prolonged /obstructed labour (Table II).
In most cases there was overlapping of more than one contributory factors. Moreover, in each category of contributory factors, 50-70% belonged to inborns.
This and other studies8,9 has shown higher neonatal mortality among males compared to females (1.5:1). It may be due to the fact that male newborns are at higher risk of contracting disease or acquire slow rate of maturity of their lungs10 Two third of this mortality was among the LBW babies and two third of these were preterm. High mortality among LBW preterm babies observed in this study has also been reported from Lahore (community based)3, Karachi11,12, Brazil13 and Stockholm9. Three fourth of this mortality was seen in newborns delivered by SVD at home or in a hospital. Those delivered at RGH were mostly outcome of unbooked, complicated or high risk pregnanci6s. This has also been supported by a study from Karachi and indicate poor antenatal and perinatal health services in the country.
Twenty-two percent of this mortality was constituted by deaths within 1st 24 hours and 88% within 1st week of life again reflecting poor perinatal and obstetric services. Similar findings have been reported from Pakistan14,15 and other developing countries16. More than half of deaths occurred within 1st 24 hours of hospitalization suggesting that these babies were admitted in critical condition. This could be because of delay in seeking medical advice due to lack of timely recognition of disease or late referral due to paucity of trained personnel and physicians. Moreover, almost all the local private hospitals and even the district hospitals lacked trained personnel and necessary equipment for neonatal resuscitation.
Leading causes of neonatal mortality were neonatal infections and birth asphyxia followed by IRDS, MAS and congenital malformations. This observation is supported by both local hospital and community based studies6. A substantial number of neonatal deaths were due to LBW (mostly preterm) followed by maternal medical disease and complicated deliveries.
1. The state of world’s children; UNICEF, Oxford University Press, New York, USA, 1993; 1-24.
2. The state of the world’s children 1998. UNICEF, Oxford University Press, New York, USA.
3. Jalil F, et a!. Early child health in Lahore, Pakistan: IX. Pennatal events. Acta
Pediatr Scand. 1993;Suppl 390:95-107.
4. Government of Sindh and UNICEF. Situation analysis of children and women in Sindh. UNICEF. 1993.
5. Bhutta ZA. Epidemiology of neonatal sepsis in Pakistan. An analysis of available evidence and imptications for care. JCPSP., l996;6:12-17.
6. Bhutta ZA. Priorities in newborn care and development of clinical neonatalogy in Pakistan. Where to now? JCPSP, 1997;7:231-234.
7. Suleiman 0. Mortality from tetanus neonatorum in Punjab (Pakistan). Pakistan Paediatric J., 1982;6:152-83.
8. Chaudhry MZ, Mustansar M, Chaudhry MY. Neonatal mortality in Pakistan. A hospital based study. Specialist 1992;8:13-21.
9. Lagercrantz H, Katz Salmon M, Forssberg H. Neonatal mortality and morbidity at the children’s centre, Karolinska Hospital. Acta Paçdiatr Suppi. 1997;419:11-15.
10. Khoury MJ, Marks JS, McCarthy BJ, et al. Factors effecting the sex differential in neonatal mortality. Am. J. Obstet., Gynaec., 1985;1 51:777-82.
11. Korejo R, Jafarey SN. Perinatal mortality in Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre, Karachi, J. Pak. Med. Assoc., 1991;41:151-54.
12. Hasan H, Mirza S, Hussain M. Perinatal mortality at Sobhraj Maternity Home. Pak. Paediatr. J., I 992;16(4): 195-201.
13. Zulini MT. Bonati M, Sanvito E. Survival at nine neonatal intensive care units in Sao Paulo. Brazil. Paulista collaborative group on neonatal care. Rev. Anam Salud Publica., 1997;2(5):303-9.
14. McCormick JB. Maternal and infant mortality. In: Maternal and infant mortality: Policy and interventions. Report of an international workshop at Aga Khan University, Karachi. UNICEF, 1994;95-104.
15. Fikree FF, Gray RH. Demographic survey of the level and determinants of perinatal mortality in Karachi, Pakistan Pediatr, Perinatal Epidemiol,, 1996; 10:866-96.
16. Carvalho ML, Silver LD. Reliability of certification of the basic causes of neonatal deaths: Implications for the study of preventable mortality. Rev. Saude. Publica., 1 995;29(5):342-8.