Saima B. Memon ( Department of Medicine, Aga Khan University, Karachi. )
Abdul M. Memon ( Department of Medicine, Aga Khan University, Karachi. )
Objective: The objective of this study was to find out the level of knowledge the physicians and lay people have pertaining to the effect of cigarettes, why certain physicians smoke and what measures could be applied to reduce the rate of smoking. Methods: A questionnaire was administered to the one hundred physicians who smoke, one hundred non-smoking physicians and one hundred lay people who smoke to determine their attitude towards this addition. Subjects were chosen using convenience sampling. The physicians were picked from six hospitals of Karachi.
Results: When the smoking physicians were asked what could motivate them to stop smoking, majority of them said that an occurrence of a smoking-related illness would. Majority of the physicians who do not smoke felt that individual will was the greatest force keeping them from smoking. When asked how smoking can be reduced in Pakistan, majority of the physicians, both smoking and non-smoking, favoured mass health education. Lay smokers expressed marked ignorance about deleterious effects of cigarette smoke. Like smoking physicians, majority of them said that occurrence of an illness related to smoking would effectively motivate them to stop smoking.
Conclusion: Based on this survey we conclude that mass health education and enforcement of the ban on smoking in public places will effectively reduce the number of smokers. There is a need to educate physicians and the general public about the cardiac and carcinogenic effects of smoking (JPMA 49: 2, 1999).
The hazards associated with smoking are becoming increasingly obvious. The Pakistan Health Education Survey 1992-93 estimated that about every third adult smoked at the time of survey1. The tobacco industry also now acce2pts that the products present in a cigarette are harmful to health . Cigarette smoking or the use of tobacco has been associated strongly with a wide range of diseases2 including cancer of the mouth, throat, larynx, lungs, bladder, emphysema and comnaiy heart disease3. It has also recently been documented that smoking increases the risk of lower urinaiy tract symptoms4. A 40-year follow-up study of British Physicians, showed a Strong relationshipbetween smoking and increased mortality from as many as 24 causes5. In spite of this a number of physicians continue to smoke. Cigarette smoking is expected to rise in the third world in the coming years. Effective modalities will be required if rate of smoking is to be curtailed. Physicians will be on the forefront in the waragainst smoking. Most patients stop smoking when told by their physicians. Are smoking physicians effective motivators? This study was done to find ways and means in curb the menace of smoking by studying the behaviour and attitudes of smoking physician and to
• compare their views with those of non-smoking physicians and lay smokers.
Materials and Methods
A cross sectional questionnaire study was conducted. The criteria for enrolment for a physician was an M.B.B.S. degree. Physicians were chosen from six hospitals by walking through corridors and going to various departments and wards. Of the six hospitals, four of them were teaching hospitals and medical colleges. Of the six hospitals two were catering to the upper economic class, two were to the middle and two served underprivileged. Lay smokers were picked at random by walking on the streets of Karachi. Physicians were allowed to fill the questionnaire themselves whereas the lay smokers were administered interviewer based questionnaires. The survey was limited to men as ladies rarely admit to smoking in our society. To be classified as a smoker the respondent should smoke at least one cigarette per day on regular basis. Three groups were made with one hundred participants each. Group I consisted on smoking physicians, group II comprised of lay people who smoked and group Ill included physicians who did not smoke. A trend analysis was done and the data was analysed on Epi Info Ver. 6.0.
We foundit quite difficult to get physicians to admit that they smoke. Most of the physicians who smoke apparently do so in privacy. Many of them were caught red handed while smoking. A candid tobacco industry executive once said that each doctor who smokes is worth hundreds of thousands of dollars to the industry but this is definitely an understatement6. In developing counthes there has recently been an increase in the number of young men who are smoking7,8. Pakistan is no exception.
The results of this cross sectional study proved to be quite alarming. It was observed that smoking physicians acknowledge the risk factors of smoking more as compared to non-smoking physicians. In spite of this fact 59% of the smoking physicians said that occurrence of a smoking related illness would make them stop and 22% said that nothing would motivate them. This is concordant with observations from earlier studies that knowledge abou the ill effects alone are inadequate to eliminate this habit9,10. The lay people onthe other hand were not quite knowledgeable about the ill effects of smoking in relation to heart (67%) and its carcinogenic effects (65%).
When questioned about the ways to eliminate this menace from the country we observed that all the three groups were thinking along the same lines. The most chosen category was mass health education by all three groups. Restriction on the local production and import. of cigarettes was suggested mainly by lay smokers. Our respondents did not feel that higher cost of cigarettes would discourage smoking. A study in Australia concluded that leaching about tobacco and related disease is necessary forthe future doctors to increase theirown knowledge about smoking and counselling their patients about this addiction11.
As long as physicians continue to smoke it will be very difficult for them to motivate their patients to give up smoking6,12. However, many ex-smoking doctors believe that patients are much more likely to listen to their advise as they can relate to what the patient is going through13. In New Zealand, doctors continue to lead the community in non-smoking and their goal of achieving a smoke free medical profession by the year 2000 seems to be achievable14.
Based on suggestions given by our respondents we recommend:
1. To increase the awareness about the hazards of smoking, a mass health education compaign should be launched. The most vulnerable age is between 10-18 years15. Schools should play an active role inthis campaign. Centre for communicable diseases (CDC) analysed data from 1997, Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Finding indicated that among US high school students in 1997, 70.2% had tried smoking. Among students who have ever tried smoking, 35.8% went on to smoke daily16. Parents spending time at home with children should not smoke17.
2. Ban on smoking in public places should be enforced.
3. Promotion of cigarettes on television should be banned. Cigarette companies should notbe allowed to sponsor sporting events.
1. Pakistan Health Education Survey 1991-1992. Islamabad, Ministry of Health Government of Pakistan, 1993;pp.115-1 22;
2. Jafarey NA. Tobacco (editorial) J. Pak, Med. Assoc., 1998;48:6 1.
3. Alam SE. Prevalence and pattern of smoking in Pakistan. J. Pak. Med. Assoc., 1998;48:64-66.
4. Koskimaki J. Association of smoking with lower urinaiy tract symptoms. i. Urol.. 1998;159:1580-1582.
5. Doll et al. Mortality in relation to smoking: 40 year’s observations on male British doctors. Br. Med. J., 1994;309:901.
6. Champan S. Doctors who smoke. Br, Med. J., 1995;311(7010):945.
7. Peto R. Smoking and death. The past 40 years and the next 40. Br. Med. J.. 1994;309:937.
8. Mackay JL. The fight against tobacco in developing countries. Tubercle Lung Disc.. 1994;75:8-24.
9. Deman U, Demir G, Akan P. Is awareness of its risk enough to stop people from smoking I. Cancer, Edu., 1995;10:68-70.
10. Merchant AT. Luby SP. Parveen G. Smoking among males in a low socioeconomic area of Karachi.. J. Pak. Med. Assoc., 1998;48:62-63.
11. Richmond RL, Kehoe L. Smoking behavior and attitude among Australian Medical Students. Med. Edu., 1997;31 :169-76.
12. Samuels N. Smoking among hospital doctors in Israel and their attitudes regarding anti-smoking legistation. Public Health, 1997;1 11 :285-88.
13. Ebdy MJ. Doctors who smoke. Zealotry is counter productive (letter). Br. Med. J., 1995;3 11(701 0):945.
14. Hay DR. Cigarette smoking by New Zealand doctors and nurses: Results from a 1996 populationcensus. N. Z. Med. J., 1998;1 11(1062): 102-104.
15. Sadruddin A, Agha F. Teenager’s smoking: A great ‘public Health problem. Renewing the pool of smokers. J. Pak. Med. Assoc., 1996;46:284-86.
16. Selected cigarette smoking initiation and quitting behaviors among high school students- United States. 1997. MMWR. Morb. Mortal Wkly. Rep., 1998;47:386-9.
17. Ashley MJ, Cohen J, Ferrance R, et al. Smoking in the home: changing attitude and current practices. Am. J. Public Health, 1998;88 :797-800.